Every single day of the week, the Agribusiness Development Corporation (ADC) dumps millions of gallons of water polluted with pesticides and heavy metals into the ocean in areas where Kauai’s west side residents fish, surf and recreate with their families.
This is not wild speculation, exaggeration or hysterical hyperbole.
United States District Court Judge Derrick K Watson on July 9th, 2019 ruled that the ADC is polluting the waters off of west Kauai and doing so without a permit required by the federal Clean Water Act.
Please read the court decision yourself: https://earthjustice.org/sites/default/files/files/Order_Summary-Judgment-and-Dismissal_2019-07-09.pdf
Read the court decision and then send out your mahalo to community groups Na Kia‘i Kai, Surfrider Foundation, and Pesticide Action Network — and most especially the law firm Earthjustice who represented them.
Yes, the unfortunate reality is that it took private action by local residents and private nonprofits to press the issue in federal court and finally begin to hold this state agency accountable.
The ADC is a public agency who manages public agricultural lands. They are knowingly and consciously polluting public waters daily without a permit.
It gets worse. Please read the court decision yourself, it will blow you away.
The court findings are eyeopening and include statements such as:
“There is no question (emphasis added) that ADC discharges polluted water into the near-shore waters of the Pacific Ocean off Kauai’s western coast on a daily basis via the Mānā Plain drainage ditch system, and that it does so without an NPDES permit…It is undisputed that the water discharged contains various pesticides and agricultural chemicals, byproducts of agricultural chemicals, and heavy metals (emphasis added), as well as sediment from the unlined canals through which it passes.”
“…chemicals that seep into the drainage ditch system, including amniomethylphosphonic acid (AMPA), a degradate of glyphosate; dichlorodiphenyldichloroethylene (DDE), a degradate of dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethane (DDT); glyphosate, ametryn, atrazine, bentazon, chlorpyrifos, cispropiconazole, diuron, fipronil, hexazinone, MCPA, metolachlor, prometryn, propoxur, simazine, and trans-propiconazole…”
The ADC and the agrochemical industry based on Kauai’s west side will of course be quick to assure the public that the above listed toxic soup of “various pesticides and agricultural chemicals, byproducts of agricultural chemicals, and heavy metals…” are all there in only small amounts and it’s perfectly safe to swim in them. A “little bit” is ok they will tell you.
But they won’t tell you that for some of these chemicals there is no acceptable level of exposure for a fetus. They will also not tell you that chronic exposure to “a little bit” every day over decades results in negative health impacts that have yet to be fully understood. Scientists and medical professionals alike though will agree that long term exposure to even small amounts of these chemicals is not good for your health, nor for the health of our reefs and nearshore fisheries.
If you live on Kauai’s west side, I encourage you to make an informed decision: Take a second to google these chemicals, read their labels and decide for yourself if you want to continue taking your family to the beach or eat the fish caught from the nearshore waters.
The ADC manages tens of thousands of acres of state-owned agricultural lands located primarily on Kauai and on Oahu. Their largest tenants are the agrochemical corporations (Dupont, Dow, Syngenta/Hartung, etc) doing genetic research and growing thousands of acres of GMO seed corn on Kauai’s west side. These same tenants apply tons of Restricted Use Pesticides (RUP’s) on a regular basis to crops grown on the adjacent fields.
The ADC is the enabler of the pollution but not the originator. The contaminants themselves are generated by the ADC’s industrial tenants and then make their way into the ditches managed by the ADC, and then into the nearshore waters.
The application of RUP’s is controlled by federal law, which strictly prohibits them from being used in a manner that allows them to drift on to neighboring properties or waterways. The mere presence of these pesticides in the ditch water and ultimately in the ocean is de facto evidence that the companies using these chemicals are breaking the law.
It is reasonable, that our community should expect our state government to investigate the source of the contaminants and enforce the law.
It is reasonable to request that the governor and the Department of Agriculture mandate that the ADC review its tenant leases and include provisions further prohibiting them from applying RUP’s in a manner that allows them to drift or runoff into the ditch system and ultimately the ocean.
It is reasonable to levy stiff fines and penalties should the ADC and/or their tenants – continue to pollute and contaminate Kaua’s nearshore waters. The ADC and these tenants know the law and yet they continuously and consciously seek ways to circumvent those requirements established to ensure public safety.
And finally, the ADC should immediately stop discharging this contaminated ditch effluent into the nearshore west side waters until they secure the permits they are legally required to have. The permit process allows for further public disclosure and closer scrutiny as to the nature, volume and source of the pollutants. The EPA and the State Department of Health can as a condition of the permit, set pollution limits as well as specify reporting and enforcement parameters.
Please read the court case in its entirety. It’s easy reading and very informative. Read the case and then after your anger and disgust subsides…call the governor and each of your elected representatives. Ask them for action and for accountability – our community deserves it.
First published in The Garden Island Newspaper 7/16/19