Shopping Cart Diaries #5 – On defending thieves and drug addicts

I received yet another irate, somewhat irrational, yet also thoughtful email – outraged that I am defending drug addicts and thieves.

Am sharing my response below, as we all – “think this through”.

Aloha,

I appreciate the thought and time you put into this response.

And I understand somewhat the frustration and anger that comes from having your personal space and life – intruded upon by these folks and anyone really who might trespass upon your private property.

You say “These homeless are thieves and burglars. For the safety of society they need to be stopped!”

It is no doubt true that the homeless population includes some who steal AND I agree, thieves and burglars should be arrested and prosecuted.

However, the research is clear. The great majority of homeless are just poor people, older people, and families with children.

And if a person on the street comes across an abandoned shopping cart, and adopts it – is that really theft?

If they found a stray dog and adopted it, is that “stealing”?

The owner of the shopping cart and the dog should be first and foremost responsible for keeping their property secure AND just because someone downline eventually gains possession of that property – doesn’t mean they stole it.

You also say, “They live on the slopes of Diamond Head. They have no respect for the Aina. There’s no bathroom facility close by.”

This, without a doubt is the fundamental issue, not shopping carts but identifying a safe, legal, and accessible place for these people to go to.

At the moment this doesn’t exist.

While “space opens up” on some days for some people at various shelters, there’s no legal, safe, accessible place for the thousands of homeless that exist today in our community.

Where would you have them go?

To jail?

The cost of arrest, trial, conviction, and incarceration (for what? Stealing a shopping cart? Trespassing? Urinating in the bushes?) would be astronomical, not to mention inhumane.

Toughening the laws against possession of a shopping cart is not the answer.

Our government should first and foremost create “safe zones” and shelters so when they’re told to move, they have someplace legal, safe, and accessible to move to.

Then, if they refuse to “move”, yes cite them for trespassing and engage the legal system to prosecute as needed.

But until there’s some legal place to move to…conducting “sweeps” and toughening the shopping cart laws only push people from one illegal place to another while further criminalizing poverty.

Sincerely,
Gary Hooser

If you live in Honolulu, I ask also that you take ACTION with regards to Bill 53 “The Shopping Cart Bill”:

Email TODAY!

Council Member Esther Kia’aina ekiaaina@honolulu.gov
AND
Council Member Matt Weyer mweyer@honolulu.gov

Please tell them both, MAHALO for voting NO, on Bill 53!

AND please also email the Honolulu City Council Members below and ask them politely and professionally of course, – to please reconsider their present support for Bill 53 and also vote NO.

Please send your email ASAP as Bill 53 is expected to be scheduled for its next hearing soon.

Andria Tupola atupola@honolulu.gov
Tommy Waters (Council Chair) tommy.waters@honolulu.gov
Scott Nishimoto scott.nishimoto@honolulu.gov
Tyler Dos Santos-Tam tdossantos-tam@honolulu.gov
Val Aquino Okimoto valokimoto@honolulu.gov
Augie Tulsa atulba@honolulu.gov

Bottom line message for the Council Members AND to ALL –

We’re all in this together.

Let’s figure out a way together, to solve our many challenges without further hurting our brothers and sisters who sit at the very bottom of the socioeconomic ladder.

Let’s focus our energy instead, on offering them a hand up.

Gary Hooser

Screenshot

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Lessons from the ledg – Organizing the House, the Senate, County Councils, and Congress – A game of thrones or democracy in action?

Insiders call it “Organizing”, and it’s happening at this very moment – in Congress, in that big square building on Beretania Street, AND at County Councils across the islands.

Actually it’s happening across the continent.

Following every general election, before the successful candidates are actually sworn into office, they talk amongst themselves, sharing “what they want” and who they are likely to support for key leadership and committee positions.

Those who now occupy those seats will be fighting hard to remain in those slots, and holding on to that power.

The “newcomers”, the “outsiders”, and those who sit on the margins, will be seeking of course to increase their own power and influence.

Whoever has “majority” support – wins.

For the Kauaʻi 7 member Council that’s 4 votes. In the other Hawaiʻi Counties with 9 member Councils the magic number is 5.

In the Hawaiʻi State Senate, whoever has 12 friends, can be Senate President or Chair of Ways and Means (WAM). For the State House it’s 26, the U.S. Senate is 51, and in the U.S. House 218 is the number.

As soon as any individual or “faction” is able to “lock in” the number of votes needed to achieve majority support, they will then lock in each and every leadership and committee position, and the “rules” governing how the power is used and distributed among themselves.

“I’ll support you to be House Speaker, if you support me being Chair of Finance…” is an oversimplification, but you get the picture.

Sometimes the “majority” needed to “organize” is pieced together one vote at a time, and other times it occurs when various “factions” join together.

“I’ll bring my 9 friends along with me, to join your group of 11, and we can divide the key leadership/committee positions among our groups. Now we just need to find 5 or 6 more votes and close the deal.”

This same process occurs in every legislative body – everywhere.

In Hawaiʻi, the votes needed to “organize” the House and Senate are normally secured from within the majority Democrats. However if short a few votes – the dominant faction may bring in friendly Republicans to secure the votes needed.

What about Green Party member Pāʻele Kiakona, recently elected to the State House, and newly declared “Independent” State Senator Brenton Awa?

Will they be brought into the “organizing conversation”, treated fairly, or banished to the margins?

Will they be appointed to serve on the most important committees, or just tossed a few crumbs and assigned to the most insignificant positions?

What would happen if other “dissident” (outspoken and left-leaning) incumbent Democrat or Republican House/Senate members, also decided to join the Green Party, become an Independent, or simply align and join forces with them?

What a can of worms (or great opportunity) this could turn out to be.

The answer of course is leadership that organizes based on inclusivity, and on respect and equal treatment for each and every member – regardless of whether they are part of the “winning factions”.

Squeezing out voices that disagree only motivates those voices to be louder, and sometimes disruptive. (The media loves these members).

Attempting to silence contrary opinions is not leadership, and it’s certainly not democracy.

Encouraging committee members to sit quietly so as to “get through the agenda”, as quickly and smoothly as possible, is a disservice to those elected to serve, AND to the community who shows up, seeking to participate.

As the “organizing”, conversation proceeds, my hope is the principles of genuine inclusivity prevail – for the individual elected members AND for the general community.

Bringing diverse ideas and opinions to the table, having a civil public discussion, listening to the pros and cons, and then holding a public vote.

This is what democracy looks like.

Yes, the committee meetings might run a little longer, and the public nature of the discussion and public vote might be awkward for some – but it’s the right thing to do AND it’s required by our State Constitution.

Gary Hooser

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

In response to an email citing my audacity to defend the houseless – relating to the Shopping Cart Diaries #4 11/14/26

An email came in yesterday saying simply, “So should your stolen bike or car that is abandoned somewhere in the city be unlawful and should you the owner of stolen property be liable for your stolen property littering the city?”

This person had read my recent blog post “Shopping Cart Diaries #3” where I wrote somewhat facetiously (but not really) that the City and County of Honolulu should create a “Shopping Cart Leash Law”, and make the business owners themselves responsible for making sure their shopping carts don’t leave their property – similar to a dog owner and a leash law.

My response:

“Thank you for the excellent question!

First – if someone steals something, then that’s already against the law, as it obviously should be. 

However, if the rightful owner of that stolen object was negligent in securing it in the first place (thus in essence inviting it to be stolen), then the negligent owner bears some responsibility for the harm caused by the stolen object. 

This legal principle is used to hold negligent people accountable for their negligence.
 
So if a stolen shopping cart is left in the middle of the road because it was stolen, both the person stealing it and the person that was negligent in keeping it secure (if that’s the case) share responsibility. 

Of course if the owner of the shopping cart made a good faith effort to keep it secure, the degree of negligence and resulting responsibility, would be minimal to nonexistent. 

Using the “leash law” example – If the owner of a dog allowed it to wander the neighborhood “unleashed”, and the dog was subsequently befriended and adopted by another neighbor or person passing by – that person would not be seen as “stealing” the dog.  

And if that dog then did something bad, both it’s new “adopted owner” and the owner that failed to keep it on a leash, could be responsible.

The original owner of the dog is responsible for keeping the dog in their yard and/or on a leash, with a collar, and that collar could have a GPS monitor and or other mechanisms to locate the dog, and or keep it from wandering out of the yard. 

And if someone did come into the yard and actually “stole” the dog, took the dog down the street and abandoned it, and then someone else came along and adopted the same loose dog – this second person was simply taking care of an abandoned dog and did not steal it. 

Think shopping carts. Same.

Yes, it’s complicated.

If the primary objective is to protect shopping carts, and the public from their misuse, the first and most important step in the process is to require shopping cart owners to better secure and manage their own property.

I’ve been in supermarkets that require small deposits, returned when you return the cart. Others have people outside at the entry to the parking lot, actively monitoring, collecting, and returning the carts. Locking wheels and GPS are increasingly common. 

It’s already against the law to steal a shopping cart. Piling on additional criminal charges and the resulting expense to the poorest people in our community, AND the taxpayer expense of police, attorneys and courts – doesn’t make sense on many levels.

Mahalo for being part of this conversation.

Sincerely,
Gary Hooser

To readers and community: Please read up on Bill 53 (I’ve posted several pieces on my garyhooser blog “Shopping Cart Diaries #1, #2, #3 and now today #4). The ACLU is also deeply engaged in this issue.

Please, it’s oh so important that you email TODAY, Council Member Esther Kia‘aina ekiaaina@honolulu.gov AND Council Member Matt Weyer mweyer@honolulu.gov and tell them both, MAHALO for voting NO, on Bill 53!

Please also email the other Honolulu City Council members listed below and ask them politely and professionally of course, – to please reconsider their support for Bill 53 and Vote NO.

Andria Tupola
atupola@honolulu.gov

Tommy Waters (Council Chair)
tommy.waters@honolulu.gov

Scott Nishimoto
scott.nishimoto@honolulu.gov

Tyler Dos Santos-Tam
tdossantos-tam@honolulu.gov

Val Aquino Okimoto
valokimoto@honolulu.gov

Augie Tulba
atulba@honolulu.gov

Bottom line message for the Council Members AND to ALL –

We’re all in this together.

Let’s figure out a way together, to solve our many challenges without further hurting our brothers and sisters who sit at the very bottom of the socioeconomic ladder.

Let’s focus our energy instead, on offering them a hand up.

Gary Hooser

Screenshot

Posted in Uncategorized | 8 Comments

The “Shopping Cart Diaries” #3 – an ongoing saga

Background I posted “Shopping Cart Diaries #1” a week or so ago, and then just a few days ago I posted #2: update on that nasty Bill 53 trying to protect shopping carts from poor people (includes a “cut and paste” StarAdvertiser story.)

One of the “pro Bill 53” complaints cited in the story was, “Everyone’s quick to say this is a bad idea but no one is offering solutions…”. (paraphrased).

So…I’ve been thinking about this and voila!

Here it is, in all it’s facetious glory!

Treat loose shopping carts like we do loose dogs and make the OWNERS responsible for their shopping carts getting loose and into the roadway, or on to other peoples property.

It’s simple really, the City and County of Honolulu should just amend the existing dog “leash law” like this:

§ 12-4.1 Definitions.

Stray or Stray (Dog) Shopping Cart. Any (dog) shopping cart

(1) On the premises of a person other than the owner of the (dog) shopping cart, without the consent of an occupant of such premises; or

(2) On a public street, on public or private school grounds, or in any other public place, except when under the control of the owner by leash, cord, chain, or other similar means of physical restraint; provided that the leash, cord, chain or other means is not more than 8 feet in length; and provided further, that this provision will not be construed to permit that which is prohibited by any other law.

§ 12-4.2 Stray(s) Shopping Carts prohibited.

It is unlawful for the owner of any (dog) shopping cart to permit the (dog) shopping cart to become a stray.

There you have it.

While it may seem ridiculous, the bottom line is:

The owner of the shopping cart should be responsible for keeping the shopping cart on their property. They can use “locking wheels” or “shopping cart monitors” or whatever.

If indeed shopping carts are dangerous, and in effect an “attractive nuisance” then the owner of that shopping cart should be held responsible.

Why should taxpayer dollars be spent, and police, prosecutor, and judicial systems burdened to fulfill a responsibility that rightfully belongs to the private business owner?

And yes, other cities do require the business owner to monitor, control, retrieve, and be responsible for their own shopping carts.

Please, if you’ve read this far and if you live in Honolulu, email TODAY:

Council Member Esther Kia‘aina
ekiaaina@honolulu.gov

AND

Council Member Matt Weyer
mweyer@honolulu.gov

And tell them both, MAHALO for voting NO, on Bill 53!

And if you can, please also email the others below and ask them politely and professionally of course, – to please reconsider their support for Bill 53.

Honolulu City Council Members:

Andria Tupola
atupola@honolulu.gov

Tommy Waters (Council Chair)
tommy.waters@honolulu.gov

Scott Nishimoto
scott.nishimoto@honolulu.gov

Tyler Dos Santos-Tam
tdossantos-tam@honolulu.gov

Val Aquino Okimoto
valokimoto@honolulu.gov

Augie Tulba
atulba@honolulu.gov

Bottom line message for the Council Members AND to ALL –

We’re all in this together.

Let’s figure out a way together, to solve our many challenges without further hurting our brothers and sisters who sit at the very bottom of the socioeconomic ladder.

Let’s focus our energy instead, on offering them a hand up.

Sincerely,

Gary Hooser

Screenshot

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

You gotta be willing to ask. Something I try my best to teach others.

It’s been a crazy few days, weeks, months…

MAHALO PLENTY to each and every one of you who has recently sent me via personal check or VENMO @Gary-Hooser-1 a gift in support of the work I’m doing.

We are about half way to our goal!

My heart is filled with gratitude and appreciation for your help and support.

Whether it was $10, $12.72, $100, $300, or $500…each is meaningful AND will be put to good use – of that I promise you.

On top of the multiple hurricanes, and seemingly endless rain AND the normal stress and strains of life AND the elections – honestly I’m starting to wear a little thin.

The support that’s coming in though, is a shot in the arm (positive metaphor intended) 😉

My plan is to take a break until December 1, celebrate Thanksgiving with family, and rest up a bit.

Then return and pivot with gusto towards the coming year.

Increasingly, I’m most happy when I’m writing.

And walking of course. The morning walks, the rainbows, the “sky on fire”, the mountains, and watching the moon set and the sun rise at the same exact time – is awe-inspiring to say the least.

Note: I’ve taken a break from walking as my ankle has taken a break from falling 😉 Nothing life threatening but the MD said I need to “stay off my foot and wear the boot” for the next few weeks.

I’ve recently gotten several notes from friends asking me “Is everything ok?” AND “How can I help?”

The short answer is YES, besides the recent tumble of course, everything is actually better than ok 😉

And yes, it goes without saying the challenges of life surround me and you both.

But all’s good and getting better.

And I totally appreciate you asking.

And YES you can help.

It’s something I try to teach those young emerging leaders heading out to change the world.

I tell them “You gotta be willing to ask. You’re asking adults and they can say no, or not now maybe later, or they can ignore you – but you gotta ask. If you believe in what you’re doing – you gotta ask.”

So, here it is.

I’m asking.

And I definitely believe in what I’m doing.

Yes, I have expenses involved in the work and day-to-day advocacy that is my life.

And yes, I could use some help.

I’m not asking you to pay me to do this work, because I will do it anyway, whether I am paid to do it or not.

I’m not asking for payment, I’m humbly requesting a gift.

There’s no tax deduction as I’m not a tax deductible organization, nor any organization at all.

I’m just me, Gary Hooser, trying my best to do good, and be better.

No gifts received by me will be used for any political donation nor for any lobbying.

You are not paying me to lobby. I will voice my opinion on public policy regardless, and will not accept any gift that is intended to pay me to lobby or reward me for lobbying.

The fundamental goal that drives my advocacy is inspiring, educating, and teaching others how to best get involved, and take ownership of their government and their democracy.

The help I need at the moment are funds to support the basic infrastructure allowing me to teach and educate others on the reality of “how things work” in the world of policy and politics.

My technology skills are limited, and in my dreams I’d hire someone to help update my website, maintain and upgrade the MailChimp service (which has outgrown it’s existing plan), and expand my social media presence.

In addition, I could use help supporting the exorbitant inter-island airfare rates being charged by Alaskan Airways.

To stay properly connected with friends and allies on all islands require “day trips” which involve airfare, Uber expenses, and coffee for all those coffee shop meetings.

Yes, I can and do Zoom, but occasional face to face meetings are important as well. (And there’s an annual fee for a proper Zoom account too).

And yes, if you are an English major or school teacher, you will know that I could use help with editing and proof-reading 😉

So…if you can help with a personal gift of support (no amount is too small) via VENMO @Gary-Hooser-1 It would be totally awesome.

If you prefer to give the ole fashion way, a personal check to Gary Hooser, 5685 Ohelo Rd, Kapaa, HI 96746 also works!

No corporate gifts nor any gift over $1,000 will be accepted.

If you can help, mahalo plenty, if not, I totally understand.

No worries.

My work will continue, regardless.

My goal is to raise $10,000 between now and December 1 and we’re about half way there.

Mahalo for reading this far.

Mahalo for helping if you can.

Mahalo for anything and everything you are doing to help make our world a better place.

Sincerely,

Gary Hooser

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Shopping Cart Diaries #2 – A quick update on the Honolulu shopping cart fiasco.

Yep…in case you missed the news or my prior post Shopping Cart Diaries #1 , The Honolulu City Council is hard at work trying to figure out how to protect shopping carts from poor people.

Here’s the update: The Council voted 7-2 Thursday, with Council members Esther Kia‘aina ekiaaina@honolulu.gov and Matt Weyer mweyer@honolulu.gov voting NO, to approve the second of three readings for Bill 53.

HONOLULU RESIDENTS:
PLEASE EMAIL BOTH – ASAP – AND TELL THEM THANK YOU!

AND PLEASE EMAIL ALL OTHERS AND ASK THEM TO RECONSIDER THEIR SUPPORT AND INSTEAD OPPOSE BILL 53!!
https://www.honolulucitycouncil.org/home/#councilmembers

According to the StarAdvertiser:

“Bill 53 is set for another hearing before the Council’s Public Safety and Economy Committee, followed by another full Council meeting to consider its final approval. The next full Council meeting is scheduled for Dec. 2, which is expected to be Waters’ final meeting before he terms out of office.”

How sad/ironic/unfortunate is that? Dec. 2 – The room will be full of people both applauding the outgoing Chair Tommy Waters for his service AND slamming his outgoing Bill 53 proposal that seeks to further criminalize the poorest of the poor.

My hope is that Bill 53 will be deferred indefinitely and/or perhaps amended to a Resolution establishing a “Task Force” or “Working Group” that can better examine the alternatives available (including the no-action alternative).

Please – email Councilmembers Esther Kia‘aina ekiaaina@honolulu.gov and Matt Weyer mweyer@honolulu.gov and tell them thank you!

Aloha,

Gary Hooser

Honolulu City Council advances shopping-cart bill despite homeless concerns
Honolulu StarAdvertiser By Ian Bauer 11/09/26

Profanity-laced testimony from one opponent and widespread criticism from others failed to put the brakes on a controversial Honolulu City Council measure aimed at curbing shopping-cart theft and abandonment, as Bill 53 advanced despite claims that it unfairly targets Oahu’s homeless population.

The Council voted 7-2 Thursday, with Council members Esther Kia‘aina and Matt Weyer dissenting, to approve the second of three readings of a measure that would broadly prohibit possessing, using or offering shopping carts for use in the city unless they are clearly identified by their owners and used under specified conditions.

Introduced in July by Council Chair Tommy Waters, the latest version of Bill 53 classifies violations as petty misdemeanors. It removes an earlier proposal for fines of up to $2,000 and imprisonment for up to 30 days, but does not specify a fine amount or jail term.

Under the measure, shopping carts would have to display conspicuous markings identifying their legal owners. Owners or people authorized by them could possess and use identified carts on property they own or in which they otherwise have a legal interest.

Written authorization from a property owner or an authorized representative could serve as an affirmative defense against prosecution for possessing, using or offering an identified cart outside the cart owner’s premises.

Carts owned by the federal government, as well as carts owned and being used by the state, would be exempt, the bill states.

Anyone convicted of violating the ordinance would be required to forfeit the cart to the city. Each cart in a person’s possession would count as a separate violation.

If enacted, the ordinance would take effect upon approval. Cart owners would have 180 days to identify their carts, during which no arrests or citations could be issued under the ordinance.

Waters has said the bill is not intended to target kupuna who use personal shopping carts or people experiencing homelessness.

“We have to acknowledge that stealing a shopping cart from businesses is not OK, it’s still theft,” Waters said before the Council’s vote. “You just have to walk around and you see shopping carts everywhere, they’re everywhere.”

Waters later challenged his Council colleagues to come up with a better legislative solution to the problem.

For his part, Weyer had introduced an amendment to reduce the penalty under Bill 53 from a petty misdemeanor, which carries potential jail time, to a noncriminal violation punishable by a fine, similar to a parking ticket.

But Weyer later withdrew his amendment after numerous testifiers called for the entire measure to be rejected.

Yet Bill 53 drew support from the Honolulu Police Department and the Retail Merchants of Hawai‘i during an Oct. 22 committee meeting.

HPD Maj. Paul Okamoto acknowledged the measure’s opponents believe it criminalizes homelessness on Oahu.

“However, this bill is about the possession of stolen property, and possession of property that belongs to someone else,” Okamoto said, adding “there needs to be sufficient consequence so that they understand that they are not to monopolize, take these shopping carts, and use them for their own use, monopolize its use.

“I think that’s wrong,” he added.

Dave Erdman, interim president and CEO of the Retail Merchants of Hawai‘i, also backed Bill 53.

He noted shopping carts can cost from $250 to $750 for retailers and even up to $1,000, especially when shipping to Hawaii and tariffs.

“When carts are taken without permission retailers lose valuable property, and customers ultimately bear those costs,” Erdman said, noting priorities should include “meaningful deterrents and clear enforcement tools for HPD.”

Other priorities, he said, included “protection for legitimate personal carts and authorized users, and third, and importantly, a process to return recovered carts to their rightful owners rather than forfeiting them to the city permanently.”

But most people who submitted written or oral testimony opposed Bill 53, including the city Department of the Prosecuting Attorney and the state Office of the Public Defender.

The Prosecuting Attorney’s office has acknowledged the city’s interest in addressing abandoned carts that obstruct sidewalks and create public safety hazards, but questioned whether criminal penalties would be proportionate.

The department expressed concern that a potential jail sentence for simple possession of a shopping cart outside an authorized location could raise questions about proportionality. It urged the Council to consider a non-jailable violation with an appropriate monetary penalty.

The state Office of the Public Defender also urged the Council to reject the measure.

In written testimony submitted Nov. 4, First Deputy Public Defender Hayley Cheng said shopping carts can be essential for people without housing, serving as storage and transportation for clothing, food, water, medication, identification documents and other necessities.

She also argued the measure, if enacted, would criminalize possession or use of a shopping cart even when the person had caused no harm.

“Bill 53 fails to make that critical distinction,” Cheng wrote. “Instead, it risks imposing substantial criminal penalties upon individuals for conduct that may be entirely harmless and that is closely associated with the daily realities of homelessness.”

Mandy Fernandes, policy director of the ACLU of Hawai‘i, also strongly opposed Bill 53.

“We oppose it even with Council member Weyer’s amendments, because a violation still requires somebody to show up to court,” she told the Council. “A lot of people that I believe would be targeted by this measure, and enforcement of it, are not going to be able to get themselves to court, and then that equals a bench warrant and then they get arrested.”

Fernandes described this city legislation as a waste of taxpayer-funded resources.

“This measure is cruel, it’s unnecessary, it’s ineffective, it’s expensive, it criminalizes harmless conduct, it wastes taxpayer dollars in doing so and it raises serious constitutional concerns that exposes the City and County of Honolulu to legal liability and lawsuits,” she added.

Fernandes said similar legislation “has not worked nationally” or locally.
“It’s unnecessary as Chair Waters has reminded us, there are already sufficient felonies, misdemeanors, civil laws that penalize this behavior,” she said. “If those are not sufficient deterrents then a petty misdemeanor is definitely not going to be a sufficient deterrent.

“HPD has sufficient tools in its tool belt to address this now,” Fernandes said. “And if they’re not using those to prosecute theft of shopping carts, then they need to reconsider their strategies.”

Laie resident Choon James also opposed Bill 53, questioning why the city had to be so punitive.

“It’s almost like a knee-jerk reaction,” James added. “Why does a solution to county challenges always have to be the big stick of punishment, through big fines and jail?

“And why is the stealing of a shopping cart proportionate to these criminal threats?” she asked.

Makiki resident Awapuhi Robinson said HPD should not be involved in what she characterized as a “civil matter” involving shopping cart owners.

“Are we as City Council now utilizing public services to be weaponized for corporations?” Robinson asked.

But Kaimuki resident Tim Garry supported the measure. “Much of the testimony against Bill 53 is from the ‘Homeless Industrial Complex’,” he asserted. “They give inaccurate scenarios that just aren’t true.”

Garry later proposed establishing a private fund to purchase shopping carts for those in need, likening it to “a needle exchange program,” and pledged the first $100 toward the effort.

During Council discussion, Weyer noted Hawaii’s high cost of living and the lack of affordable housing contribute to the broader problem of homelessness.

“And so I think it’s incumbent on all of us to be pushing all the tools that we need to have housing options for our community,” Weyer said.

Later, Waters said, “This Council … put hundreds of thousands of dollars in the budget to build housing for people that’s gone unspent.

“Vouchers that we get from the federal government come down and sometimes the city has said, ‘We don’t want them,’” Waters asserted. “It’s ridiculous; take them and use them.”

Waters added he was also receptive to community suggestions, including one that may see the city provide storage space for homeless people’s belongings. “Based on that, I’ve already drafted a resolution,” he said.

“And I’ll be introducing that shortly.”

Bill 53 is set for another hearing before the Council’s Public Safety and Economy Committee, followed by another full Council meeting to consider its final approval.

The next full Council meeting is scheduled for Dec. 2, which is expected to be Waters’ final meeting before he terms out of office.

OK…I couldn’t wait and just had to write the Shopping Cart Diaries #3 you can read here!

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Shopping Cart Diaries #1 – Honolulu Friends: Your urgent Honolulu City Council testimony needed NOW!

Why’s this Kaua’i guy writing about the Honolulu City Council?

Well for one thing they represent more Hawaiʻi residents than the other 3 Counties combined AND they’re setting a very bad example that I’m hoping no other County Council on any island will ever follow.

The Honolulu City Council, tomorrow, Thursday 11/05/26 at 10am – is going to meet and possibly pass into law a bad, insensitive, and just wrong on so many levels – Bill 53 that attempts to further criminalize the very poorest of the poor.

Yep. The Honolulu City Council is hard at work trying to figure out how to protect shopping carts from poor people.

GMAFB – These people are literally sleeping on the streets with all their worldly possessions inside that shopping cart. Some are working and cannot afford the sky high rents, some have medical issues and cannot afford medical treatment, and yes, some have substance abuse problems.

And the answer is to take away their shopping carts?

I don’t think so.

Please, please, please if you live on Oahu, Please contact YOUR Honolulu City Council Member and ask them to kill Bill 53. No amendment or deferral can salvage this.

Please also email in testimony, and show up in person if you can. Even if you don’t testify at the hearing, your presence in the room is important. Submit testimony for the Honolulu City Council meeting ASAP and no later than tomorrow, November 5 @10 AM: https://hnldoc.ehawaii.gov/hnldoc/testimony BILL053(26)
RELATING TO SHOPPING CARTS.

Of course it’s already illegal for anyone to steal anything from anyone.

Do we really need to “toughen the law” and crack down on those living at the very bottom of our social and economic ladder?

Ask the Council to “kill the bill” and focus instead on the comprehensive solutions already proven to work.

Every County needs to improve access to mental health services and substance abuse treatment.

Every County needs to increase the availability of affordable housing, safe zones, and homeless shelters.

I encourage Councilmembers in every County to do what I did a few months ago. No Room at The Inn – My own, eye-opening experience, attempting to help.

Put on your “anonymous citizen’s hat” and call the homeless shelters in your County. Call and do your best to locate a safe and dry place for your imaginary houseless friend to sleep tonight.

When you eventually reach a live person, they’ll say, “Tell your friend to come in, fill out an application, and when something opens up, we’ll let them know.”

So…the person who’s really houseless, dirt poor, and living on the street, must push their shopping cart who knows how many miles, down to the shelter, fill out the application, and then wait for the telephone call (assuming they have a phone and further assuming it’s charged up and working).

And for most, that call may not come for days, or weeks, or longer – depending on many factors.

To my friends in Honolulu – On behalf of the most vulnerable people on the planet, please let your voices be heard – tell the Council that Increasing the supply of true affordable housing is the answer, not taking away shopping carts.

Read the next update: Shopping Cart Diaries #2 AND Shopping Cart Diaries #3…and yes…there will be more

Submit testimony NOW for the Honolulu City Council meeting tomorrow, November 5, 10 AM:
https://hnldoc.ehawaii.gov/hnldoc/testimony

Posted in Uncategorized | 9 Comments

A “blue wave”, a temporary mirage, or an opportunity for action and meaningful change?

It was a defacto “blue wave” – a tidal wave actually.

So, why do I keep waiting for the other shoe to drop?

The election’s over.

But not really.

Clearly, the money changers at the top who control the data, the algorithms, and the very thoughts and images that enter our brain – are not done.

At least that’s my prediction.

The Trump administration and his enablers are not going to accept losing.

Whether it’s a “false flag” attack on the homeland, a dramatically expanded war with Iran and/or Ukraine, a global economic collapse, or some high tech incursion into our voting system – something’s going to happen.

Call me paranoid, call me “Debbie Downer”, or call me a realist.

But I just cannot imagine President Donald J. Trump or the ultra wealthy high tech bro’s who put him there – accepting defeat.

I hope and pray that I’m wrong.

While I believe in the power of prayer AND in the power of hope and positive thinking – I believe even more so in the power of action.

Individual, focused, collective action towards a common goal of making our world a better place is the answer.

To both maintain our sanity and to tangibly improve and protect people and the planet – we must take action and we must start now.

Yes, we had a “blue wave” and Democrats will soon be in control of Congress.

But as my friend Nina Turner loves to say, “Any old blue won’t due”.

We must now, at this moment in time, call upon ALL members of Congress to be the leaders we voted for and so desperately need.

I mean literally CALL directly your/our U.S. Senators and Representatives. The U.S. Capitol Switchboard operator will connect you directly with their office (202) 224-3121.

NOW. Today.

Congratulate them on their win, thank them for their service, AND tell them now, clearly, and unequivocally – that they must select new House and Senate leadership from among their members who truly believe in putting people and the planet above corporate profits, and who feel the same urgency of the moment we do.

We don’t need no stinking corporatists, who call themselves centrists, and only masquerade as Democrats.

We need real Democrats, who really believe in this stuff – at every level of government.

And we need at the local and national level, a Democratic Party that holds elected officials who carry the “D” brand, accountable to supporting those core Democratic Party values.

Housing, healthcare, education, living wages, eliminating our dependency of fossil fuels, protecting our natural environment, and providing humane and equal treatment under the law to every human being must be our focus.

We need to eliminate the Department of War, and create instead a Department of Peace.

Yes, of course we need a strong “defense”, but our focus must be on mutual understanding, reconciliation, food, medicine, homes, hospitals, and schools – NOT bigger bombs, smarter drones, space weapons, biological, or A.I. killing machines.

The ultra wealthy who benefit from public funds, services, and infrastructure, must be held accountable and pay their fair share.

So please, CALL YOUR U.S. SENATOR AND HOUSE REPRESENTATIVE TODAY. The U.S. Capitol Switchboard operator will connect you directly with their office (202) 224-3121.

Seriously. We can and must do this.

Otherwise what?

Can you really look away and act like you don’t see it?

Your country kills school girls at Shajareh Tayyebeh. We are the largest provider of weapons and the second largest polluter on the planet.

Each and every day, you drive by people living at the side of the road. There’s no affordable housing, no room at the homeless shelter, no mental health services available to them, and no jobs for them that pay a living wage.

Yes, you can ignore what’s going on, or you can get involved, take action, and make a positive difference.

Trust me, you’ll feel much better when you get involved and take action.

To be clear, no elected leader is going to take us to the promised land.

It’s up to you.

I can and will do my part, of that you can count on.

But unless you join me, my effort will be like spitting in the wind

However with you and me, and our collective friends and neighbors joining together – we can become that wind and blow wide open those doors now shut tight to the positive change we need.

CALL YOUR U.S. SENATOR AND HOUSE REPRESENTATIVE TODAY. The U.S. Capitol Switchboard operator will connect you directly with their office (202) 224-3121. Just give them your zip code if you’re not sure who to ask for.

AND while your asking them to support House/Senate Leadership who truly believe in putting people and the planet first, tell your Senators LOUD AND CLEAR TO VOTE NO on BAAJA, or the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act – giving the fossil fuels industry unprecedented tools to force approval of their dirty energy projects AND stripping away environmental protections.

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

General election thoughts/results as of 9:45am 11/04/26

Winning.

While that’s the short answer, it will still be a few days at least to know the full extent of the win, AND on the national level – what response will yet be forthcoming from the Trump administration and his enablers.

Here’s a quick summary of where things are as of 8am Wednesday morning with a focus on those races I’ve been posting on over the past few months or so. (All subject to change and I’ll update as I learn more)

There was a defacto “blue wave” – a tidal wave actually – at both at the State Capitol AND in Washington D.C..

Since I’m a firm believer in the words of Nina Turner who reminds us always that, “Any old blue won’t due” – I won’t beat that drum any further.

I’ve listed below those local races I’ve been following most closely and have put in bold candidates I’ve been actively supporting on all islands – “If I lived in the district”.

I’m hugely pleased to report that here at home in the CD2, U.S. Representative Jill Tokuda, a true blue Democrat I’m proud to support – won hands down against her well known and camera friendly opponent.
(D) TOKUDA, Jill N. 108,369 65.2%
(R) AWA, Brenton 48,764 29.3%

For too many reasons to list here 😉 I took no position on the Kaua’i Mayor’s race.

Kaua‘i Mayor
RAPOZO, Mel 13,927 56.5%
CARVALHO, Bernard, Jr. 9,208 37.4%

For Maui Mayor
BISSEN, Richard T., Jr. 27,567 54.8%
SUGIMURA, Yuki Lei Kashiwa 21,409 42.6%

Most readers who’ve been following my posts in the recent months know that my main focus has been on the Kaua‘i, Maui, and Hawaiʻi County Council races.

Here’s the current vote ranking for the Kaua’i County Council. Note, the top 7 vote-getters will serve on for the upcoming two years.

NOTE to ALL candidates: I sending all my best wishes and huge mahalos to all, AND I’m looking forward to working together with all in the future to help make our collective communities and our world a better place, whether via serving in public office and/or working directly in community.

HOLLAND, Fern Anuenue 12,425 7.2%
OZAKI, Todd R. 11,557 6.7%
KANESHIRO, Arryl J. 11,501 6.7%
CORREA, Michelle Kaleiohi 11,486 6.7%
BULOSAN, Addison 9,684 5.6%
SMITH, Dane 9,243 5.4%
APPLEGATE, Paul Noboru 8,456 4.9%
SHIGEMOTO, Taylor H. 8,235 4.8%
DECOSTA, Billy D. 8,048 4.7%
COOTS, Mike 7,166 4.2%
MARTIN, Umi 6,431 3.7%
RAPOZO, Cheree 5,842 3.4%
KAIMINAAUAO, Keola 5,091 3.0%
MATTOS, John H. (Scooby) 4,190 2.4%

For the Hawaiʻi County Council my focus has been on only one race:
Councilmember, Dist 5
RODENHURST, Ikaika 3,166 49.6%
MATSON, Shannon Lopeka 2,659 41.7%

And on Maui, the Council races I’ve been following/supporting:

East Maui –
SINENCI, Shane 25,063 49.8%
CARROLL, Claire Kamalu 16,325 32.4%

West Maui –
PALTIN, Tamara Akiko Maile 30,389 60.4%
TILLMAN, Mark 12,320 24.5%

Kahului –
BATANGAN, Kauanoe 22,273 44.3%
KAMEKONA, Carol Lee 20,266 40.3%

South Maui –
KING, Kelly Takaya 23,686 47.1%
COOK, Tom 20,942 41.6%

Upcountry –
PAHIA, Bobby 30,381 60.4%
YOKOUCHI, Jon Masaru 12,681 25.2%

Lanai –
JOHNSON, Gabe 33,271 66.1% (won outright in the Primary)

Molokai –
RAWLINS-FERNANDEZ, Keani 33,123 65.8% (won outright in the Primary)

What about the Honolulu City Council? Honestly for me the Honolulu Council is a bit of a mystery. Between their current focus on taking away shopping carts from those at the very bottom of the food chain, to the recent Sunshine Law apparent violations/shenanigans – it’s all too convoluted (nicest word I could think of at the moment) for me.

The 6 State (Oahu and Maui) legislative seats I’ve been actively following/supporting, “If I lived in the district.”

State Senate District 18
Mililani and Waipiʻo Gentry
(D) BASS, Danielle Maliekekai 6,938 53.3%
(R) KITASHIMA, Kelly Puamailani 5,119 39.4%
(N) HANNA, Max G. 239 1.8%

State House District 14
West Maui
(G) KIAKONA, Pa’ele 2,991 41.1%
(D) PATEL, Sne 2,884 39.6%
(R) COCHRAN, Elle 1,236 17.0%

State House District 39
Royal Kunia, Village Park, Honouliuli, Ho‘opili, Portion Waipahu
(D) ROSENLEE, Corey 3,419 62.2%
(R) DEGRACIA, Daniel (Danny) 1,908 34.7%

State House District 42
Portions Varona Village, ‘Ewa, Kapolei, Fernandez Village
(R) GARCIA, Diamond 2,512 49.4%
(D) PARIS, Anthony Makana 2,440 48.0%

State House District 43
Kapolei and Makakilo
SOUZA, Kanani 1,855 34.8%
MEDEIROS, Sheila 1,695 31.8%

State House District 45
Wai‘anae, Mākaha
Kalehua Koala
(R) MURAOKA, Chris 1,643 51.8%
(D) KAOPUA, Kalehua 1,463 46.2%

The hot potato – State Constitutional question #2 regarding “Rise Bonds”
YES 195,307 63.2%
NO 88,954 28.8%

Again…what you are seeing above is from information available as of 8am this morning November 4th.

Some of these races are very close and may change as the “final print-outs” are published later today.

Please check out the data yourself, direct from the source at the office of elections: https://elections.hawaii.gov/election-results/

AND – I will be writing more on this…sharing my thoughts and hopes and proposed actions we need to take in the future (as in right now).

Please share my blog with others www.garyhooser.blog

AND go to https://www.garyhooser.com/ if we’ve never met and you would like to find our more about me AND sign up for my weekly email missives/reports/ramblings (I refuse to call it a newsletter). It is NOT a newsletter!

Imua.

Gary Hooser

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Two exceptional candidates for the Hawaiʻi State House who can win, who are pushing very hard, and who especially need your help today.

Are you as sick and tired of those television ad’s as I am?

The constant stream of mailers has subsided, but the television ads are starting to turn my stomach.

I’ll be oh so glad when November 3 comes and goes. But we gotta push all the way through until the end AND we gotta help even more today, in these final all important days, those truly exceptional candidates who’re out there working hard to serve us in elective office.

At the national level, regardless of “which side” wins, there will be allegations of fraud and election manipulation.

I cannot imagine the MAGA forces accepting a loss of power in Congress.

To survive (both literally and figuratively) the madness that’s forthcoming on the national level, our focus must be on thinking globally while acting locally.

If you’re interested in my own state-wide voting recommendations (but please do your own homework), check out – “Who I am voting for and who I would vote for if I lived in the District”. I also share here my thoughts on the State Constitutional questions.

To make positive change truly happen, your vote AND your help NOW spreading the word to encourage others to do the same – is essential.

If you’re a friend and reader who truly believes in our democracy and in a position to help these two State House candidates especially – Anthony Makana Paris HD 42 and Kalehua Kaopua HD 45 – PLEASE SEND THEM A CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTION TODAY – whether it’s $20 or $200, a donation of any amount TODAY if possible but no later than the end of the day 10/31/26 will help them make their final push.

If either or both of these candidates win, the impact could be far-reaching. They’re running hard and both races will for sure be close. Please help them if you can.

The purpose of my regular outreach via this posting and my regular email sent out each week, is to enroll your support in making positive change happen throughout our community.

And yes, I’ll say it out loud – To help make our world a better place.

My intent is to share with you, some of what I’ve learned over the past 36 years serving as a State Senator, a County Council member, AND in the private nonprofit world of political and policy advocacy.

I encourage you to be involved, let your voice be heard, and join me in making a difference.

After all, we’re all in this together.

Sincerely,
Gary Hooser
www.garyhooser.blog
Former Hawaiʻi State Senator, State Senate Majority Leader, Councilmember, non-profit community advocate, policy and politics blogger, grandfather, and many other things. – “Who is this guy Gary Hooser and why is he emailing me?”

Rushing to get this out…apologize for the typo’s and grammatical snafus…

NOTE: It’s likely too late to trust the mail so to be sure your vote is counted, please visit a Voter Service Center or Ballot Drop Box! Locations statewide are here (scroll to General Election).

Please take a moment if you have not already done so to read “My Policy And Politics Epiphany – Think County Councils”.

AND Please encourage your friends and networks to join my email list by going here.

Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment