There are 26 candidates running for election to the 7 member Kaua’i County Council.
On August 8, the top 14 vote getters will move forward to the General Election.
Based on past elections, candidates ranking #1, #2, #3, and #4 in the Primary will generally be considered “safe” and almost guaranteed to win on November 3.
Slots #5, #6, #7, #8, and #9, are where the “action” and “movement” will be, as these 5 candidates battle it out, hoping to end up in the winners circle at #7 or above.
It’s rare for #9 or #10 to move up to #7, AND never, ever, does #14 move up the 7 slots needed to win.
Obviously finishing in the top 7 on August 8th is desirable, but to have a real chance and maintain momentum heading into the General, a candidate must finish at least in the top 10 (IMHO).
On November 3rd, Kaua’i voters will choose their top 7 (elected from the 14).
Once elected, all decisions of the 7 member Council are decided by “majority vote”, which means 4 is the magic number.
Ideally, the entire Council works together as a team with each member serving in a position that best suits their individual experience, skillset, and capacity.
The reality however is that 4 members can run the show.
4 Council members working in alignment will choose the new Council Chair, decide what measures pass or fail, which Mayoral appointments are approved or not, and to a great extent County budget priorities.
Yes, 4 is the magic number.
To override a Mayoral veto requires 5 votes, so 5 is an even more magical number, but a 4 vote majority is what it takes to run the show.
The collective “mindset” of the Council majority determines everything.
The majority could be forward thinking, assertive and willing to take action to move our community forward.
Conversely, the Council majority may be timid, unwilling to “rock the boat”, and prefer instead to just hold tight, maintain the status quo, and say yes to whatever the Mayor wants.
Or the majority could be “fluid”, dysfunctional, contentious, and unable to work together.
Each voter may cast “up to 7 votes” for 7 different candidates, but there’s no requirement that all 7 votes must be cast.
Akamai voters who understand the voting dynamics will cast their votes wisely, and only vote for those candidates they truly believe in, AND will likely work well together.
Experienced voters will never, ever, ever, vote for their favorite top 4 or 5 and then go “eeny, meeny, miny, moe” to cast the final 2 or 3 votes.
Nope. Smart voters realize the 6th or 7th vote they cast could beat out their top choices, by their own one vote.
Think about it, and ask “If you were running, who would your mother vote for?”
Naturally, she would vote for you.
But if she voted for you AND then cast her other 6 votes for 6 others, those votes could be the same votes that beat you. Imagine losing an election by a single vote that was cast by your own mother.
But of course, I am nobody’s mother 😉
My voting strategy in the Primary is to help boost my choices of the best newcomers “up” on the list of 14, and then in the General focus mostly on those in the critical “middle slots” of #5, #6, #7, #8, and #9.
With that in mind – I will be voting for Fern Holland, James Trujillo, Trysten Fernandes Caberto, Mike Coots, Umi Martin, and Michelle Kaleiohi Correa in the Primary on August 8th.
I am purposefully only voting for a single incumbent, Fern Holland, because I want to give more space and a little more boost to the newcomers.
Of course all 26 candidates care about our community and want to do good. And each brings different strengths and weaknesses to the table.
But I/we must make a choice, and after thinking long and hard about this, speaking directly with candidates, reading the websites, the Civil Beat interviews, and talking to others – I believe these 6 share my core values, AND will serve in a manner that is proactive, working together with their colleagues, and our community, to resolve the many challenges facing our island home.
As good hearted as they may be, I’m not looking for “space-holders” that just sit there. I’m also not interested in voting for “talkers” who posture for the camera, then do nothing. My votes will go to doers who have a history of showing up.
End Notes: The Hawaiʻi Sunshine Law HRS Chapter 92 forbids more than 2 members of the Council from meeting in private to discuss County business. Consequently any Council majority must have their discussions and make their decisions in a properly noticed public meeting where the public is given an opportunity to speak. It’s illegal for 3 or more members of the Council to meet in private and discuss County business, whether that meeting is in their Council office, on Zoom, in a restaurant or bar, in someones living room or kitchen, or via “serial communications/text/phone/email”.






