I received yet another irate, somewhat irrational, yet also thoughtful email – outraged that I am defending drug addicts and thieves.
Am sharing my response below, as we all – “think this through”.
Aloha,
I appreciate the thought and time you put into this response.
And I understand somewhat the frustration and anger that comes from having your personal space and life – intruded upon by these folks and anyone really who might trespass upon your private property.
You say “These homeless are thieves and burglars. For the safety of society they need to be stopped!”
It is no doubt true that the homeless population includes some who steal AND I agree, thieves and burglars should be arrested and prosecuted.
However, the research is clear. The great majority of homeless are just poor people, older people, and families with children.
And if a person on the street comes across an abandoned shopping cart, and adopts it – is that really theft?
If they found a stray dog and adopted it, is that “stealing”?
The owner of the shopping cart and the dog should be first and foremost responsible for keeping their property secure AND just because someone downline eventually gains possession of that property – doesn’t mean they stole it.
You also say, “They live on the slopes of Diamond Head. They have no respect for the Aina. There’s no bathroom facility close by.”
This, without a doubt is the fundamental issue, not shopping carts but identifying a safe, legal, and accessible place for these people to go to.
At the moment this doesn’t exist.
While “space opens up” on some days for some people at various shelters, there’s no legal, safe, accessible place for the thousands of homeless that exist today in our community.
Where would you have them go?
To jail?
The cost of arrest, trial, conviction, and incarceration (for what? Stealing a shopping cart? Trespassing? Urinating in the bushes?) would be astronomical, not to mention inhumane.
Toughening the laws against possession of a shopping cart is not the answer.
Our government should first and foremost create “safe zones” and shelters so when they’re told to move, they have someplace legal, safe, and accessible to move to.
Then, if they refuse to “move”, yes cite them for trespassing and engage the legal system to prosecute as needed.
But until there’s some legal place to move to…conducting “sweeps” and toughening the shopping cart laws only push people from one illegal place to another while further criminalizing poverty.
Sincerely,
Gary Hooser
If you live in Honolulu, I ask also that you take ACTION with regards to Bill 53 “The Shopping Cart Bill”:
Email TODAY!
Council Member Esther Kia’aina ekiaaina@honolulu.gov
AND
Council Member Matt Weyer mweyer@honolulu.gov
Please tell them both, MAHALO for voting NO, on Bill 53!
AND please also email the Honolulu City Council Members below and ask them politely and professionally of course, – to please reconsider their present support for Bill 53 and also vote NO.
Please send your email ASAP as Bill 53 is expected to be scheduled for its next hearing soon.
Andria Tupola atupola@honolulu.gov
Tommy Waters (Council Chair) tommy.waters@honolulu.gov
Scott Nishimoto snishimoto@honolulu.gov
Tyler Dos Santos-Tam tdossantos-tam@honolulu.gov
Val Aquino Okimoto valokimoto@honolulu.gov
Augie Tulsa atulba@honolulu.gov
Bottom line message for the Council Members AND to ALL –
We’re all in this together.
Let’s figure out a way together, to solve our many challenges without further hurting our brothers and sisters who sit at the very bottom of the socioeconomic ladder.
Let’s focus our energy instead, on offering them a hand up.
Gary Hooser
