GaryHooser's Blog

Mahalo for taking the time to check in and read this blog once in a while. I do my best to keep my posts informative, useful, entertaining if possible – and not too long.

If you want more… Please consider subscribing to my email rant-letter or political action-letter or whatever you want to call it…but it’s not a newsletter! Please…I truly hate the term and I certainly don’t read newsletters.

Please also watch our newest – Policy + Politics video podcast via YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/live/THJnzO2FfPQ?si=ZL6fQqLw24lgL82f

or Policy + Politics via FaceBook https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1ZU7RN7sda/

The shows are all recorded and available to view anytime. Please take a moment to watch and/or just listen…and let me know what you think. We are new at this and your feedback is greatly appreciated.

My co-host extraordinaire, Aria Juliet Castillo, is on vacation and so yesterday’s show was just me!

It’s basically “Hooser unleashed” :-).

I promise to do my very best to deliver 90 minutes of coherent, interesting, and valuable policy and politics content.

If you have specific questions or issues you would like me to talk about…please respond here to this blog post…and again feedback and suggestions on how we might improve…are welcome 😉

Your’s truly,

Gary Hooser
former lots of things…but forget the titles
Just call me tūtū man

Months ago Hawai’i legislators were told to hold August 25-29, September 29-October 3, and November 17-21 for a possible special session to deal with the anticipated Trump budget cuts.

The Legislature convened a special session in 2017 to deal with the Honolulu fixed rail project.

One would think hauling people away in the middle of the night without due process, and the Trump Administration attacks upon all areas of civil society would warrant at least the same degree of attention as “rail”.

One would think.

The needs are great and we cannot wait until the next regular session.

There’s nothing regular about the times we’re living in.

Coming up with the State funds necessary to offset the impacts of Federal funding cuts impacting Hawai’i public schools, health care, nutrition assistance, environmental protection, and other essential public services – is priority #1.

“Fixing” the deeply flawed SB933 (4 politicians empowered to award $50,000,000 to nonprofits behind closed doors) is just one of several legislative actions, that cannot wait until the “regular” session.

Mahalo to Representative Della Belatti for proposing this fix and strongly speaking in support of convening a much needed special session. Mahalo also to Representatives: Kim Coco Iwamoto, Kanani Souza, and House Majority Whip Amy Perruso for joining in that support.

Rep. Perruso also supports including in the special session a measure prohibiting law enforcement officers from hiding their identity behind masks while making arrests, requiring visible credentials, and ensuring due process. In addition she’s advocating for passage of a bill banning state contractors and their immediate families from donating to political campaigns (pay to play).

These 3 items: No secret police, fix SB933, and close the contractor “pay to play” loophole – represent a good start.

I believe however the people deserve more.

We have an affordable housing crisis that needs emergency ACTION, not just an emergency declaration.

Sweeping the unsheltered from public view should be the crime, not sleeping in your car or in the bushes at the side of the road – when there’s literally no other legal place to sleep.

Restoring faith and confidence in government, must also be a priority.

Strengthening campaign spending laws, ending the “two ticket to a fundraiser” scam allowing the transfer of money between candidates, closing the “contractor family and friends loophole”, and passing publicly funded elections – would be huge steps in the right direction.

Special sessions can be called by the governor or by a two-thirds vote of the House and Senate and may last up to 30 days.

Please join me now in reaching out to every legislator in that big square building.

Contact first, your district Senator and Representative – (name/contact info here https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/fyl/ ) AND then contact Senate President Ronald Kouchi (808-586-6030 senkouchi@capitol.hawaii.gov ) and House Speaker Nadine Nakamura (808-586-6100 repnakamura@capitol.hawaii.gov ).

Let them know you’re counting on them to support a special session.

Should they say there’s not enough time in a special session to do what’s needed, remind them they can and should start now, form working groups, hold hearings, fine-tune bills – and then during the actual 30 day special session conduct the final hearings and votes.

Inevitably they will bring up the money, or lack thereof.

Remind them gently yet firmly that last year they approved tax cuts that will cost Hawai’i over $1.4 billion per year. (Hawai’i Appleseed)

Suggest that perhaps during the special session they should claw back a billion or so from the wealthy beneficiaries of both the Hawai’i 2024 tax cuts and those contained in Trumps BBB.

We need thoughtful, proactive, positive action, not excuses for putting things off to another day.

That day is now. Please make the calls and send the email.

Let’s do this.

Gary Hooser

I just posted this comment on a StarAdvertiser story where the governor and others are quoted saying we don’t need a special session because the really bad stuff hasn’t happened yet…so my comment is “Yes absolutely makes total sense to me. Why hold a special session now to be proactive prior to the actual crisis arriving? Why not just wait for bad things to actually happen first before troubling our part-time legislative leaders? After-all everything else is totally on track. The number of masked ICE enforcers have not yet gotten the headlines here that deserve a response. Let’s wait until something really bad that makes super headlines that alarms even more tourists before we take proactive steps. Our unsheltered have sufficient, safe, clean, and weather resistant (almost) tents to live in (so long as they move on every few weeks) AND we already gave them an emergency declaration! Surely they can wait until a regular session? Our contractors and their friends and family members can still contribute to political campaigns, and the need and frequency of political fundraising can now move full speed ahead, without being hindered by cumbersome regulations. Oh yes…SB933 which is now law…will allow 4 of our best legislators to dispense $50,000,000 to nonprofits in their districts and across the islands from the privacy of their closed door meetings. What could go wrong? We don’t need no stinking special session when we have the status quo which is working just fine!”

If you agree a Special Session is yes most definitely needed NOW please
Contact first, your district Senator and Representative – (name/contact info here https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/fyl/ ) AND then contact Senate President Ronald Kouchi (808-586-6030 senkouchi@capitol.hawaii.gov ) and House Speaker Nadine Nakamura (808-586-6100 repnakamura@capitol.hawaii.gov

Here’s the story “Special Session May Not Be Needed”

Thinking of Congressman and civil rights activist John Robert Lewis (1940 – 2020) AND hoping you will consider joining me and many others this coming Thursday July 17 in stirring up and supporting “Good trouble, necessary trouble”.

* Hilo: 3 – 5pm Pauahi St and Kamehameha Ave. Hilo Bayfront

* Kailua-Kona: Queen Kaʻahumanu Hiwy near Mormon Temple 4 – 5 p.m.

* Naʻalehu: Hwy 11 near the Naʻalehu Post Office from 4 – 5pm

* Waimea (North HI): Mamalahoa Hiwy near Parker Ranch Center 4 – 5 p.m.

* Oʻahu: From noon – 1:30 at the State Library (featuring several “speakers”)

* Maui: At Queen Kaʻahumanu Center from 4:30 – 6 p.m.

* Kauai’i: Along highway/sidewalk, Kukui Grove, Macy’s 4:30-6:00 p.m.

NOTE: The above times and locations are from FaceBook posts primarily – Indivisible, the ACLU. Various organizations are sponsoring and co-sponsoring various events and the above is not intended to be an all inclusive list (and details may have changed). Please google or call around or ask your friends to confirm times and locations – then SHOW UP!

I’m writing today while thinking of Congressman and civil rights activist John Robert Lewis (1940 – 2020) AND hoping Kauai’i residents will consider joining me and many others in supporting his spirit of making “Good trouble, necessary trouble” by showing up and speaking out – this week especially!

Important Public Meeting
Kapaa Middle School
Tuesday July 15, 2025 5:00 pm – 7:00 pm
4867 Olohena Road

Topic: Hokua Place https://www.hokuaplace.com/
900 housing units proposed for the hillside behind the middle school.

The developer will be presenting this project to the community and this is a great opportunity to learn about, and speak out about traffic, drainage and wastewater impacts. In addition, this meeting is an opportunity to voice your opinion on the “affordable housing component” being proposed. Is it real? Is it enough? Are the promises being made by the developer backed up in writing? Is our local government going to enforce and hold the developer accountable to fulfill their promises?
*******************************************************************************

* Thursday July 17 4:30-6:00 p.m. Mahalo to Kauai’i Indivisible for your leadership in organizing this “Good Trouble” sign-holding event along the highway fronting Kukui Grove (outside Macy’s). Let’s all join together to express our concern and outrage — about the direction in which the United States of America is headed under the present administration. Bring a sign if you can, with your own message stated loud and clear!
******************************************************************
Other important actions that need your support this week are related to the U.S. Navy and NASA’s release of a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for PMRF and NASA’s Kōkeʻe Park Geophysical Observatory.

There are three meetings on this topic. Please attend one if you can.

* Tuesday July 15, 2025 5 – 8 p.m.
Kaua’i Veterans Center

* Wednesday, July 16, 2025 5 – 8 p.m
Kekaha Neighborhood Center
 
*. Thursday, July 17, 2025 5 – 8 p.m.
Sheraton Kauai Coconut Beach Resort

The Navy and NASA will provide a public overview of the Draft Environmental Impact Statement, describing and disclosing proposed uses and expected environmental, health, and cultural impacts (Section 106 – National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA). Public questions and comments will also be accepted.
***************************************************************
And still yet one more important “good trouble action” is the Wailua Wastewater Treatment Plant – Draft Water Pollution Permit coming before the Department of Health. Your email comments on this are needed by July 26! Send to cleanwaterbranch@doh.hawaii.gov and cc hlilley@surfrider.org

If you think it stinks now, just think about what it will smell like IF they approve this permit as it is now written, IF the 350 hotel rooms built at Coco Palms are built AND IF 900 homes at Hokua Place are approved.
*********************************************************************

Read on for more information on the PMRF DRAFT EIS process AND Wailua Wastewater Treatment Plant – Permit.
********************************************************

SENDING IN PUBLIC COMMENTS ON THE DEIS IS IMPORTANT and may be submitted at the public meetings, and/or via the website ( https://pmrf-kpgo-eis.com/ ) by 11:59 p.m. (HST) Thursday, August 7, 2025.

The Draft EIS documents are here: https://pmrf-kpgo-eis.com/documents/

These meetings are conducted by the Navy and NASA. Concerned residents must also look at what’s not being said and not being disclosed. Remember too that indirect, cumulative, and secondary impacts, must ALL be examined – as well as the more obvious direct impacts.

Back to the stench we smell almost daily driving past Lydgate.

Allowing the ocean water of one of our islands premier family beach parks to be continuously contaminated by partially treated sewage is not ok.

The Wailua Wastewater Treatment Plant is an aging facility built in a floodplain and tsunami zone with a history of failing pipes, sewage spills, and ever-present stench.

This facility has needed a serious upgrade for decades. This area holds deep cultural significance to Native Hawaiians with two heiau within the project area.

The ocean outfall is only 30’ underwater and approximately 235 yards off the coastline.

Email the cleanwaterbranch@doh.hawaii.gov and cc hlilley@surfrider.org prior to July 26.

Explain how you use the ocean waters around Lydgate Beach Park (i.e. surf, swim, kite, windsurf, fish, gather limu)

Describe the smell, pollution or illness you may have experienced.

Say NO to dumping of partially treated sewage in our oceans.

Describe the cultural impact in a place sacred to Native Hawaiians.

Demand a stronger permit that sets real limitations, adds robust monitoring and protects public health and the reef!

Please show up, speak out, and send off that email. Mahalo plenty to Kauai’i Surfrider for taking a leadership role on this.

Gary Hooser
Here is a picture of me reflecting on how to best make some good trouble 😉

. 

Walking the coastline this morning with Claudette, I mentioned to her that my brain was full. Too much stuff going on, too many ideas swirling around, and just too many things on my mind.

Somewhat predictably her response was, “So….what are you going to do about it?”

I mumbled something about walking my way through it and for the next two hours, I walked – in deep meditation, contemplation, and self-reflection.

It seems I’m entering into yet another “rolling mid-life crisis” where the question of “what’s next” refuses to go away. Every few years this question seems to rear its ugly/beautiful head, and does not go away until fully confronted.

What will be the next step, what path will I embark on in the not too distant future?

Though technically retired, I’m not into working in the garden, playing golf, watching tv, or just hanging out twiddling my thumbs.

I think about my 4 grandchildren daily. Two are here, just 30 minutes down the road. The other two are on the continent, at least two plane rides and 24 hours away. I miss them both terribly.

Yes, all have been raised around politics and civic engagement.

My oldest granddaughter, was asked as part of her second grade class project, “What would you do if you were the President?”

Her answer, “Be kind to people.”

Yep, that’s my little girl talking.

When I recently asked my 8 year old grandson about his plans for the future. A paleontologist is what he said. He wants to be a paleontologist.

“What about you Pop Pop?” he asked, “What do you want to do next?”

“I’m not sure boy, still thinking about that,” was my reply.

“Why don’t you be President again?” he said without hesitation.

My heart melted, I gave him a humongous hug, and then tried my best to explain to him a little bit about the roles I have actually played in politics and government over the years.

I assured him that we both could achieve anything we set our minds and hearts on if we were willing to do the work, stay focused, and never quit.

I think he was about 6 years old when he reminded me one day that “Hooser’s don’t quit”, so I know that’s one important lesson already embedded in his psyche.

Bottom line for me is I’m pretty happy with the space I occupy at the moment. I write. I work to educate, motivate, and collaborate with those interested in policy and politics as a path to make the world a better place.

But yes, I want to do more.

My working life started at around the age of 16. I’ve been a newspaper delivery boy, dishwasher, carnival worker, door-to-door fire-alarm and cookware sales person, finance company manager trainee, termite house tenter, Bose Rep., Royal Aloha Club time-share presenter, Open-Air-Pedicab driver, operating engineers local 3, Fun Factory manager, small business owner – carpet and window cleaner, Realtor, developer, magazine publisher, Councilmember, State Senator, State Director of Environmental Quality Control, Vice Chair of the Hawai’i Democratic Party, co-founder Hawaii Alliance for Progressive Action (HAPA), nonprofit Board member and volunteer for various orgs, and of course — son, brother, husband, father, grandfather, and “uncle” to many.

But truthfully, while I take my daily walks, I’m thinking always there’s still new mountains left to climb, new lessons to be learned, and new opportunities to serve.

I read once that “10 years is a lifetime”. You can be an artist, a writer, an inventor, a lawyer, a whatever…for 10 years, then launch an entirely new one for the next 10 years.

I’m 71 years old, my health is good, I walk 5 miles daily, eat a mostly plant-based diet, and pound the water all day long. I wrote “Personal Reflections: Crossing bridges and walking about” describing how my health and walking journey first started.

So I’m thinking, I have at least three lifetimes yet to experience. On my bucket list is writing a book or two, being arrested (and promptly released) for (peaceful) civil disobedience, and getting a tattoo (probably the names of my grandchildren and maybe a dragon).

After that, who knows?

As I tell others – “Never say never, and always be ready”.

Mahalo to all…who are and have been part of this wonderful journey, and those also who are still yet to join me along the way…

Gary Hooser
Just call me tutu man

SB933CD1 is a “twofer” when it comes to violating Article III of the Hawai‘i State Constitution which says “legislative committee meetings held for the purpose of making decision on matters referred to the committee shall be open to the public”.

Signed into law on July 9, 2025 SB933CD1 was conceived, negotiated, and decided upon in private by a legislative committee without any public notice, review or input, AND it establishes a separate 4 person legislative committee tasked with giving out $50,000,000 to private non-profits, while exempting that new legislative committee from requirements to conduct its activities in public.

I wrote about SB933CD1 previously (A travesty of process and policy).

Today, I’d like to thank Governor Green for the “shout out” during his press conference commemorating the signing and passage into law of SB933CD1.

Yes, absolutely I’m seeking to shine a spotlight on the extreme deficiencies of this new law (to paraphrase from the remarks offered at the press conference.)

His remarks during the Q&A portion of the press conference, have both motivated me personally to push even harder on this issue AND elevated public awareness of the “constitutional deficiencies” contained within SB933CD1 (as mentioned by Representative Della Bellati in the Honolulu StarAdvertiser).

Hawai‘i Public Radio has also reported on the constitutional concerns, as has Kevin Dayton at Civil Beat who wrote “Lawmakers’ Plan To Give $50M To Nonprofits May Be Unconstitutional”, an excellent piece explaining a complicated process in easy to understand terms. AND also featured in Civil Beat today is Judith Wong, president of the League of Women Voters of Hawai‘i who writes this thoughtful piece “Bill For Hawaiʻi Nonprofit Grants Lacks Transparency”.

Mahalo Gov!

The Governor’s remarks at the press conference, and those of Senator Troy Hashimoto and Representative Daniel Holt (both members of the SB933CD1 Conference Committee), further confirmed that the discussions, deliberation, negotiations, and resulting decisions made by the Conference Committee, were all done in private – contrary to Article III of the Hawai‘i State Constitution.

Representative Holt a House Conferee said, SB933 ”was a difficult process…it did take some creativity at the end”.

Senator Hashimoto, Chair of the Senate Conference Committee said, SB933 “was given to me at the very end of the session to help negotiate…many people were involved in the discussions. The LG was doing a lot of negotiations…to make sure we can legally do this …the bill will follow HRS42F (pertaining to grants) in spirit…”

Note: Words matter. To say the bill will follow the law “in spirit” raises additional red flags…as does referencing negotiations “to make sure we can legally do this”…

There appear to be several serious legal problems with SB933CD1 including legal prohibitions on the “gut and replace” legislative practice and the separation of power between the executive and legislative branches of government.

Most importantly, Article III of the State Constitution says unambiguously “Every meeting of a committee in either house or of a committee comprised of a member or members from both houses held for the purpose of making decision on matters referred to the committee shall be open to the public.”

Clearly, these two legislators (both of whom were conference committee members), met in private with each other and others (either virtually or in person) for the purpose of making a decision on SB933 which was referred to their conference committee.

Both of these legislators and the governor alluded during the press conference to numerous meetings that were conducted as the group worked toward building a consensus and coming to their final decision.

None of these conversations occurred at a properly noticed, public committee hearing/meeting.

The public was never provided a copy of the proposed SB933CD1, never allowed to ask questions, and never allowed to testify on the measure.

Bottom line: The decision-making conducted during the creation and ultimate committee approval of SB933CD1 falls far short of Article III of the Hawai‘i State Constitution AND the proposed 4 member legislative committee (being formed to give away $50,000,000) also must comply with this constitutional mandate.

Watch on FB and Insta the actual “bill signing press conference” for SB933CD1.

It’s eerily similar to press conferences held almost daily by the President.

The script goes something like this:

The President/Governor announces some new bright and shiny action (the signing of SB933CD1), a member of the press in attendance asks a potentially controversial question (about a possible violation of the constitution), the Governor/President explodes in a petulant tirade against the person (yours truly) perceived to be responsible for exposing the problem – and of course the Governor/President never addresses the actual question or concerns raised.

Watch the press conference please and decide for yourself.

To paraphrase Hamlet by William Shakespeare.
“Me thinks, he doth protest too much”

Gary Hooser
Yes…former State Senator and Majority Leader…so I have a little bit of experience with this stuff…but do not remember it being this bad when I was there 2002 – 2010.

My recent blog/email, SB933CD1 – a travesty of process and policy, seems to have struck a chord. 

While the merits of the actual policy decision are debatable, it is absolutely clear the process violates House/Senate rules AND both the spirit, the intent and the actual language contained in our State Constitution.

I watched every single committee meeting with SB933 on the agenda. No legislative committee ever discussed publicly the bills contents, and nor were the contents of the final SB933CD1 bill ever disclosed to the public during any public meeting.

Since committee members did not meet and discuss SB933CD1 in public, obviously they had to have met in private (in person or via email or online) in order to come to a decision on SB933CD1.

If a member or members of a legislative committee met in private for the purpose of making a decision on matters referred to the committee, that would be a violation of the State Constitution Article III which states in part:

Every meeting of a committee in either House or of a committee comprised of a member or members of both Houses held for the purpose of making decision on matters referred to the committee shall be open to the public.”

While SB933CD1 is an extremely egregious example, the practice of legislative committees making decisions on matters before them in private is the norm and not the exception. If you can stomach it, please read on for more of the same.

Spilling Tea All OVER the State Constitution

My interest in HB496: Relating to Māmaki Tea was piqued recently by a piece written by Chad Blair published in Civil Beat on June 22, 2025.

Blair’s article focused on the failure of State Senator Donovan Delacruz to publicly disclose his ownership of a business that grows and processes māmaki tea. Senate Rule #85, prohibits Senators from voting on issues that constitute a direct conflict.

My first reaction to reading the story? 

I laughed out loud, in a deeply cynical kind of way.

For those in power at the legislature, rules don’t matter.

When pressed by public or private attorneys in court, legislative leadership in both the House and the Senate will say clearly and firmly that they don’t have to follow the rules if they don’t want to.

Crazy, huh? The rules don’t seem to matter and neither it seems does the State Constitution.

The passage of HB496 involved five different committee hearings, two conference committee meetings, and several “floor votes.” 

So, a few days ago, I invited my best friend Max to climb up into my easy chair with me, and together we watched the official video record of all seven public committee meetings in which HB496 was on the agenda.

Max and I watched all seven meetings. Never once was there any public discussion between committee members. There was no mention of any potential conflict of interest and there was no deliberation pertaining to HB496. 

Senator Delacruz is of course the Chair of Ways and Means (WAM), the most powerful committee in the Senate. WAM was one of the 7 Committees to hear and pass without HB496 without any discussion between committee members.

Each meeting had exactly the same formula: 

1. The Chair called the meeting to order. 

2. Public testimony was taken.

3. The Chair either went “direct to decision-making” or announced a “short recess.” 

4. When a “short recess” was called, the Chair would normally reconvene the meeting after a few minutes, and go directly into “decision-making” which equates to announcing the decision already made in private outside the public committee meeting.

NO committee member in any of the seven meetings ever asked a question, or suggested any other option or concern related to the decision being announced. 

There are only three possible situations that could drive this scenario:

1. The committee members don’t care about HB496.

2. They completely trust the Chair to make the decision without their input.

3. Individual committee members and/or the Chair’s had already met via phone, email, or in person, discussed HB496 amongst themselves, and reached a consensus on the decision in private, outside the public committee meeting.

Article III of the Hawai‘i State Constitution declares: “Every meeting of a committee in either house or of a committee comprised of a member or members from both houses held for the purpose of making decision on matters referred to the committee shall be open to the public.”

After watching and rewatching the video record of the seven different committee meetings, it seems obvious to me (and Max too) that committee deliberation and decision-making had to have occurred outside of those public meetings, because NO deliberation or discussion between committee members occurred at ANY of them.

Clearly, the seven committee meetings were held ONLY to receive public testimony and/or to announce a decision that had been made in private prior to each meeting.

Thus, the process under which HB496 passed through the legislative process did not comply with the Hawai‘i Constitution.

Hmmm. This sounds vaguely (or exactly) like Acasio v. House, the case now before the courts.  

Will see what the judge says.

Gary Hooser
Former lots of things…
Now just a tūtū man looking for good trouble
http://www.garyhooser.com
https://garyhooser.blog

I’m hoping you can join us TODAY, Monday July 7 at 5pm for our Policy + Politics video pod-cast – Trust me. It will not be boring and nothing is off the table. Please send in your questions and PLEASE ALSO SHARE THE VIDEO PODCAST WITH YOUR FRIENDS AND NETWORKS!

Responding to the DOGE and the Big Beautiful Bill by passing a law giving 4 Hawai’i politicians $50,000,000 to dole out to their friends in the nonprofit world – is a crazy bad idea. Allowing them to do it behind closed doors is political arrogance on steroids.

Here’s how it works.

SB933CD1 grants to 4 legislators (2 House and 2 Senate) the power to give out $50,000,000 in grants to nonprofits and excludes the process from the Sunshine Law. 

The actual language contained within SB933CD1:

(b)  In selecting recipients and awarding and administering grants funded by the appropriation contained in section 3 of this Act, there is established an evaluation and selection committee to oversee the evaluation and selection of, and determine grant award amounts to, nonprofit applicants.

The evaluation and selection committee shall be composed of the following members:

     (1)  Two senators appointed by the president of the senate; and
     (2)  Two representatives appointed by the speaker of the house of representatives.

“The meetings of the evaluation and selection committee shall not be subject to part I of chapter 92, Hawaii Revised Statutes.” (Sunshine Law)

SB933CD1 requires but not really – that grants be related to budget impacts/cuts currently being implemented by the federal administration.

“To be eligible for a grant funded by the appropriation contained in section 3, applicants shall be recipients or providers that have sustained a reduction or termination of their federal funding, or if the applicant is not a direct federal funding recipient or provider, the applicant shall primarily serve populations that have been negatively affected by reductions or terminations of federal funding.”

SB933CD1 is essentially a “gut and replace” (IYKYK) that started as a short form (a bill empty of content). It was then amended in the House and Senate, and ultimately assigned to a Conference Committee where it was totally rewritten with content not included in any previous version.

There was no public committee discussion or disclosure on the decision to create what today is SB933CD1. 

At the final Conference Committee meeting the Chairs very briefly summarized the content and intent of SB933CD1, the committee voted to approve, and that was it.

At no time was there any mention of the extraordinary power and discretion being granted to the 4 member House/Senate committee, nor was the sunshine law exclusion publicly disclosed.

Please. Read the bill and watch the actual hearing video online at https://capitol.hawaii.gov (search SB933)

The Conference Committee report posted as part of the official record, normally provides a summary of pertinent actions taken by the Conference Committee. In the case of SB933CD1 – this report contains no mention of the special powers granted to the 4 legislators and sunshine law exclusion.

In summary: The Hawai’i Legislature passed SB933CD1 granting 4 of their own members the power to give away $50,000,000, and to meet with potential recipients of this money in private, and to make the ultimate decision on who gets the money in private.

AND the whole process of drafting and approving the language of the bill creating this extraordinary power was also done in private – contrary of course to their own House/Senate rules and in violation of the State Constitution.

Article III of the State Constitution states in part, “Every meeting of a committee in either House or of a committee comprised of a member or members of both Houses held for the purpose of making decision on matters referred to the committee shall be open to the public.”

Clearly, the Chairs of the /Senate House Conference Committees assigned to SB933CD1 met together in private (virtually or in person), prior to the public meeting, for the purpose of making a decision.

There really is no other way these decisions could have been made – SB933CD1 did not just appear out of thin air.

Gary Hooser
Former Hawai’i State Senator
(And I do not remember it being this bad when I was there)