Does anyone really read the testimony I send in? Is it truly important that I go to the legislature’s website, log in, and submit testimony in support or opposition? Is actually showing up in person important?
Why bother? Isn’t the “fix” already in? Aren’t the decisions already made?
The answer is yes, yes, yes, absolutely yes, because it’s important, and yes sometimes, and maybe but not really.
I’ve said it once and I’ll say it again, and a thousand more times – your participation in our democracy is critically important. We, collectively must take ownership and spend the time paying attention, and yes…send in those emails, make the calls and submit the testimony.
Not every member of the committee, commission, or board will read the testimony – but some do. The media reads some of it, and other members of the public read it. And sometimes even the director or other staff members will read it.
The bottom line is volume matters. The number of people in favor or opposed to an issue, as judged by the volume of testimony and the number of people in the room – matters.
I believe the vast majority of policymakers, commissioners, board members, and staff, truly want to please the public and are uncomfortable when the public is overwhelmingly unhappy with their decisions.
But to sway those in positions of power, the public must show up.
Yes, most commissioners and board members probably come into a meeting predisposed to vote a certain way and/or just accommodate “staff’s recommendation” and move on. Likewise most legislative or council committee members lean always to accepting the “chair’s recommendation” and likewise just keep moving and not make waves.
But when the public shows up in force, when the sentiment is strong, united, and based on facts and solid reasoning – those decision-makers sometimes rethink their preset inclinations and start asking the tough direct questions themselves.
Written testimony when possible should be on time, direct, to the point, and backed with reason and facts. But truthfully…just get it in. Late is better than never and a simple straightforward few sentences for or against an item is enough. Don’t forget to include your name and the town or district where you live!
Please also send in testimony or email that‘s positive and appeals to the decision-makers “better angels”. Send support and praise when that leader does something right. All too often the loudest voices in the room are those who are upset. Sometimes harsh criticism is warranted but we must also remember to send in support and praise when deserved as well.
Showing up in person, even if you don’t speak at the meeting is important also. Just being a body in the room with other like-minded citizens is important. If you’ve never been to a Planning Commission or Council meeting or attended a legislative hearing – I encourage you to do so. It’s easy and especially as an observer, it can be enjoyable to see the people and hear the voices – live and in person.
British statesman and world leader Winston Churchill famously said, “Many forms of Government have been tried, and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.…”.
So…Democracy is what we have but it only works when people participate. So please, send in that testimony, show up at that public hearing, call your legislators – be part of our democracy.

I appreciate your research and follow up for bills like these that we aren’t given the pro & con’s of a bill (should be required for every new bill or changing a bill already been approved). How do I get to express what I think of this bill -sorry I didn’t see how to get on to the legislative website to express my opinion besides our own Rep. & Senator. Mahalo, Rebecca Kekuna
Hello Rebecca and thank you for the comment. During the legislative review process you could submit testimony during “hearings” that are held but otherwise the only other way to share your thoughts, ideas, and concerns is directly to the various legislators. Your own district Representative and Senator should be first on your contact list. Next would be the Chair of the committee the bill/proposal is being “heard”, then next in line would be the other members of that committee. I also encourage people to “join a group” such as the Sierra Club or other “advocacy organization”…these organizations often help their members “track bills” and help provide “talking points” and help guide/formulate testimony etc. I’ll be writing more on this in the near future….but excellent question. gh
Aloha Gary, as to the residential allowable additional buildings on one property; do you have an affordable or recommended value as to fair rents to be charged for say a 1Bed 1Bath…and/or a 2Bed 1Bath unit to be fair to tenants working on island at current wages being and paid and offered by the large businesses? Is $2,000 a month fair for a 1B 1Ba unit…what are your recommendations for different size units, considering grounds upkeep, bldg maintenance, utilities, wifi, property tax, insurances, mortgages, etc.? Would you post your answers on this site so my friends, family, and prospective tenants can see them. Many of us would respect your opinions on this issue. Mahalo, Zeke
Here are affordability rates quoted to qualify for property tax breaks
Click to access 2024_longterm_affordable_10.03.22.pdf
If the tenant pays any utilities
Studio $1,512
1-Bedroom $1,613
2- Bedroom $1,920
3 – Bedroom $2,207
4 – Bedroom $2,427
If the owner pays ALL the utilities
Studio $1,735
1-Bedroom $1,859
2- Bedroom $2,231
3 – Bedroom $2,577
4 -4 Bedroom $2,875
Gary,
Your advice is right on ….that an advocacy group or interest group develops a legislative agenda, writes talking points, tracks the bills, then alerts the membership to make testimony. The Hawaii Environmental Change Agents did this rather effectively this year.
And… one further step; publish for all to see A Score Card!
Conervation Voters do it:https://www.cvsc.org/legislative/scorecards/?emci=3d0a78b1-4f1f-ef11-86d2-6045bdd9e096&emdi=a320313d-8c1f-ef11-86d2-6045bdd9e096&ceid=468907
Labor Councils do it: (Washington State Labor Council has downloadable score card)
Bottom-line, distributing a legislative score card will tend to make a given legislator more accountable to constituents.
-KN
Yes!. Thank you Keith…you are so right on with these comments.